Skip to main content

MED. LIT | THE LOVE NOTE BY JOANNA DAVIDSON POLITANO

 




Focused on a career in medicine and not on romance, Willa Duvall is thrown slightly off course during the summer of 1865 when she discovers a never-opened love letter in a crack of her old writing desk. Compelled to find the passionate soul who penned it and the person who never received it, she takes a job as a nurse at the seaside estate of Crestwicke Manor. 
Everyone at Crestwicke has feelings--mostly negative ones--about the man who wrote the letter, but he seems to have disappeared. With plenty of enticing clues but few answers, Willa's search becomes even more complicated when she misplaces the letter and it passes from person to person in the house, each finding a thrilling or disheartening message in its words. Laced with mysteries large and small, this romantic Victorian-era tale of love lost, love deferred, and love found is sure to delight.


★1/2
In the summer of 1865, medical student Willa Duvall, of Brighton, England, discovers an unopened letter that had been lost in the dark recesses of her writing desk. What starts out as a curiosity about the contents and the author of the note ends up being a fateful find, when combined with a wager she makes with her father. Willa wants to attend medical school, but her father, Dr. Phineas Duvall, feels she'd be better off putting her energy into finding a suitable husband and settling down to a nice domestic life. Too bad she has no interest in marrying anyone and has turned down every potential suitor who has cared to knock on her door thus far. So her father makes a deal with her: if she can find a nursing position and succeed at it (as in, the patient shows noticeable improvement), he'll support her decision to attend medical school to further pursue her MD. But if her patient shows no noticeable change, then Willa is to return home and marry a man of her father's choosing.

As luck would have it, Willa finds a position not all that far from home, at Crestwicke Manor. This seaside estate of Golda Gresham happens to be the home of Willa's childhood friend, Gabe Gresham, the youngest son of Golda. The Gresham family also originally owned Willa's writing desk (the one holding the mysterious note), before it was gifted to Willa's father as a thank-you for all his medical service to the family over the years. Willa used to accompany her father on house calls to Crestwicke Manor, which is how she got to know Gabe.

Now, all these years later, as Willa establishes herself as the medical staff in residence, she brings along the letter to try to sniff out the answers to the question of author and inspiration of the contents. Unfortunately, the letter quickly gets out of her possession and into the hands of various members of the Crestwicke household, each new reader taking something different to heart that will ultimately alter the way they view themselves, love, even life in general. But each time, the same question comes back around: who were such loving words originally intended for?

"You needn't be afraid of your words, Miss Duvall. Only careful. They're as easy to gather as rocks, and just as easy to throw about, but don't underestimate them. I've never happened upon a neutral word." ~~ Aunt Maisie

Politano's characters are wonderfully full of life and wit, particularly Gabe Gresham and the elderly spinster Aunt Maisie. Even the characters who lean closer towards "bad guy" end of the spectrum are complex enough that you remain curious about them even if you don't particularly love them as people. Burke Gresham (Gabe's older brother) was one of the most difficult for me to root for, though there are glimpses of a softer side to him in the stories of how he wooed his young artist wife, but so much of the story in "present" time (that is, anything not in flashback memories, as this is already historical romance) seems to place him in a persistently grumpy or surly mood. I thought I was really going to dislike Dr. Tillman the whole way through, so it was nice to see him get some redeeming qualities closer to the end of the story. But that's the thing with Politano's "bad guys", the way she has you questioning whether they're honestly bad, or just misunderstood.

The tone / setting was, to me, reminiscent of some of my favorite stories in a similar vein, such as Daphne du Maurier's Rebecca or Diane Setterfield's The Thirteenth Tale. The novel features surprise after surprise right up to the very end, but not in any sort of ridiculous, obnoxiously overdone sort of way. There's also some fun nods to the actual history of the time period -- the early days of medical professionals discovering the invaluable benefits of regular handwashing (not just in environments of illness or infection, but as an everyday practice as well) and --- through Golda's daughter, Celeste --- the progression of England's suffragist movement.

The moral of the story: By all means, pursue love and marriage if you so desire, but refuse to settle for someone who undervalues your uniqueness. Hitch your wagon to someone who embraces all of you ---that means gifts, quirks, character flaws, everything --- rather than someone who pushes to mold you into a different kind of person entirely. I loved the relationship metaphor that came from Gabe working with the wild horse, "She'd given up her freedom but she had someone to go after her in a storm."

FTC Disclaimer: Revell Books kindly provided me with a complimentary copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. The opinions above are entirely my own.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

BOOKS FOR THE BIBLIOPHILES | BECOMING MRS. LEWIS BY PATTI CALLAHAN

  BECOMING MRS. LEWIS In a most improbable friendship, she found love. In a world where women were silenced,  she found her voice.   From New York Times bestselling author Patti Callahan comes an exquisite novel of Joy Davidman, the woman C. S. Lewis called “my whole world.” When poet and writer Joy Davidman began writing letters to C. S. Lewis—known as Jack—she was looking for spiritual answers, not love. Love, after all, wasn’t holding together her crumbling marriage. Everything about New Yorker Joy seemed ill-matched for an Oxford don and the beloved writer of Narnia, yet their minds bonded over their letters. Embarking on the adventure of her life, Joy traveled from America to England and back again, facing heartbreak and poverty, discovering friendship and faith, and against all odds, finding a love that even the threat of death couldn’t destroy.  In this masterful exploration of one of the greatest love stories of modern times, we mee...

SINCE YOU'VE BEEN GONE (RESTORING HERITAGE #3) BY TARI FARIS

  Leah Williams is back in the quaint town of Heritage, Michigan, and ready to try again to make her business a success. But blank slates are hard to come by, and a piece of her past is waiting for her there. Heir to the Heritage Fruits company, Jonathan Kensington is the guy who not only made Leah's past difficult, he also seems determined to complicate her present as well. Jon is trying to prove to the Heritage Fruits board that he, not his manipulative uncle, should be running the business. The board insists Jon find a new owner for the building that will house Leah's business. To avoid forcing a buyout of Leah's part of the building, Jon strikes a compromise with Leah, and the two go into business together. With her vision and his know-how, it might work. And Leah might realize he's loved her since high school. If only he didn't keep on shooting himself in the foot by boxing her out of important decisions. Sparks fly in this romantic story of two people who must...

A DRAM OF DRAMA | FUN HOME: A FAMILY TRAGICOMIC BY ALISON BECHDEL

FUN HOME   CRITICALLY ACCLAIMED, NATIONAL BESTSELLER  Time Magazine #1 Book of the Year  •  National Book Critics Circle Award Finalist  •  Winner of the Stonewall Book Award  •    Double finalist for the Lambda Book Award  • Nominated for the  GLAAD Media Award Alison Bechdel’s groundbreaking, bestselling graphic memoir that charts her fraught relationship with her late father.  Distant and exacting, Bruce Bechdel was an English teacher and director of the town funeral home, which Alison and her family referred to as the "Fun Home." It was not until college that Alison, who had recently come out as a lesbian, discovered that her father was also gay. A few weeks after this revelation, he was dead, leaving a legacy of mystery for his daughter to resolve.   In her hands, personal history becomes a work of amazing subtlety and power, written with controlled force and enlivened with humor, rich literary allusion, and...